Is Now the Right Time to Sell Your Apartment Building? Key Signs It’s Time to Cash Out

February 6, 2025

A few years ago, John and Lisa purchased a 12-unit apartment building with dreams of passive income and long-term appreciation. At first, everything ran smoothly—rents came in, expenses stayed manageable, and appreciation made them feel like investing geniuses. But then, reality set in.

A notebook with the word now written on it
The boiler broke—twice. Their best tenant moved out, replaced by one who paid late every month. City regulations tightened, increasing their operating costs. And after a conversation with their CPA, they realized they were sitting on a huge amount of untapped equity.

Like many small apartment owners, they faced the same question you might be asking yourself: Is now the time to sell?”

3 Signs It Might Be Time to Cash Out

1. You’re Sitting on a Lot of Equity, But Your Cash Flow Isn’t Growing

If your building has significantly appreciated in value, but your rents aren’t keeping up, your return on equity might be shrinking. Selling now could free up capital for better opportunities—like trading up to a larger property or moving into a different asset class.

Curious about how much equity you have and what your building  is worth? Schedule a free financial session at  ApartmentInvestingRealty.com

2. Management Headaches Are Piling Up

Maybe you’re tired of dealing with maintenance issues, tenant turnover, and city inspections. If the idea of handling another eviction makes you groan, it might be time to step away—especially while demand for apartment buildings remains strong.

3. You’re Facing Major Repairs or Regulation Changes

If your building needs a new roof, a boiler, or a costly upgrade to comply with new city rules, consider whether you want to make that investment or cash out before the expenses pile up. Selling now lets you exit before sinking more money into the property.

What’s Your Exit Strategy?

John and Lisa decided to sell. They took their gains and 1031-exchanged into a newer, less management-intensive property—one that fit their long-term financial goals.

If you’re wondering whether it’s the right time for you, let’s talk. Schedule a consultation today at ApartmentInvestingRealty.com and explore your best options.

Share by: